Play Audio
Holiday Cheer, Zero Legal Fear: A Workplace Liability Checklist
5:48

Gift Exchanges to Office Decor: A Workplace Holiday Liability Guide

By Jeanette Coleman, SPHR & SHRM-SCP on Dec 17, 2024
4 min read 0 comment(s)

Share this:

holidays and Christmas workplace compliance

The holiday season is a time for joy, celebration and cheer—but for small businesses, it’s also a time to be mindful of workplace policies and legal considerations.

To keep the season merry and bright (and free of legal headaches), here’s a comprehensive checklist to ensure your holiday activities stay compliant and fun for everyone.

1.  Decking the Halls: Holiday Decorations

Creating a festive atmosphere in your workplace can lift spirits and bring a sense of warmth to the season. However, holiday decorations need to be handled carefully to remain inclusive and avoid legal missteps.

What’s Allowed?

According to the U.S. Supreme Court and the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC), certain decorations are considered secular symbols.

These include:

  • Wreaths
  • Decorated trees
  • Candy canes, tinsel and reindeer
  • Winter scenes and strings of lights

These symbols are generally safe to display in the workplace, even if some employees object.

What to Avoid

  • Religious Favoritism 

    Avoid decorations that favor one religious belief over others. If you limit decorations, ensure the policy is applied uniformly.
  • Inappropriate Symbols

    Skip mistletoe. It may seem harmless but can lead to discomfort or even misinterpretation as condoning inappropriate behavior.

holiday party pay

2.  Respecting Religious Accommodations

Under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act, employers are required to reasonably accommodate an employee’s religious observances, provided it doesn’t cause undue hardship to the business.

Common Religious Accommodations

  • Allowing time off (paid or unpaid) for religious observances or holiday services
  • Permitting workplace prayer or other religious expressions
  • Broadening dress code or grooming policies for religious attire

How to Respond

If you deny a religious accommodation, you must demonstrate that it creates a significant burden, such as:

  • Increased administrative costs
  • Decreased productivity
  • Safety concerns
  • Infringement on other employees’ rights

Most requests during the holidays—like shift changes or vacation days—are reasonable and easy to grant. Being flexible goes a long way in fostering goodwill.

RELATED: How to Handle Holiday Vacation Requests >>

3.  Navigating Gift Exchanges

Holiday gift exchanges can be a fun tradition, but they come with important boundaries.

Guidelines for Workplace Gift Exchanges

  • Make participation voluntary to avoid pressure or discomfort
  • Remind employees to keep gifts appropriate and free from offensive content
  • Gifts or cards with sexually explicit, discriminatory or inappropriate themes can violate Title VII and your company’s harassment policies

4.  Hosting the Holiday Party

Company holiday parties are a great way to celebrate, but without clear guidelines, they can lead to unwanted legal consequences. Use these tips to keep the event festive and compliant:

Party Policies to Follow

1. Keep it Inclusive

  • Avoid religious overtones by calling it a Holiday Party or Year-End Celebration
  • Play non-religious music and decorate with secular symbols

2. Make Attendance Optional

  • Clearly state that attendance is voluntary. Mandatory attendance could mean paying nonexempt employees for their time.

3. Address Inappropriate Behavior

  • Remind employees that company policies (including harassment and conduct rules) still apply

  • Reinforce a zero-tolerance stance for inappropriate behavior, including:
     
    • Sexual harassment
    • Discrimination
    • Excessive drunkenness

how to create fair weekend and holiday schedules

5.  Managing Alcohol at Holiday Parties

Serving alcohol at company events requires careful planning to reduce risks.

If You Choose to Serve Alcohol

1. Limit Consumption

  • Offer drink tickets or a cash bar
  • Close the bar at least an hour before the party ends
  • Hire professional bartenders to monitor alcohol consumption

2. Add Safeguards

  • Serve food and non-alcoholic beverages
  • Arrange designated drivers, Uber credits or rideshare options to ensure everyone gets home safely
  • Offer incentives for employees who volunteer as designated drivers

3. Assign Sober Monitors

  • Designate managers to stay sober and watch for excessive drinking or inappropriate behavior
  • Discourage any “after parties” involving company leadership

4. Check Your Insurance

  • Consult with your insurance carrier to confirm your liability coverage for the party
  • Ensure you’re aware of any alcohol exclusions in your policy

Pro Tip

Consider holding a weekday, daytime event where alcohol expectations are lower, and employees are less likely to overindulge.

RELATED: Christmas Light Safety - Tips You Need This Holiday Season >>

6.  Taking Action If Things Go Wrong

Despite your best efforts, incidents can happen. Whether it’s inappropriate behavior, excessive drinking, or harassment, you must respond swiftly and consistently:

  • Investigate and address incidents promptly
  • Enforce company policies and take appropriate disciplinary action
  • Document everything to protect your business from further liability

Final Thoughts

The holidays should be a time of joy and celebration for your team—not a source of stress or legal challenges. By taking a proactive approach and following this checklist, you can create a festive, inclusive and compliant workplace where everyone feels comfortable and respected.

Need help ensuring your holiday policies are in line with employment laws? Axcet HR Solutions is here to help.

As Kansas City’s local certified PEO, we specialize in a full suite of PEO services, including HR, payroll, employee benefits, compliance and risk management, so you can focus on celebrating the season with peace of mind.

Happy Holidays from the Axcet HR Solutions team!

Get HR Updates

Table of Contents

ASO vs PEO: Unraveling the Tapestry of Business Solutions

ASO vs PEO
A business professional addressing poor employee performance in a workplace meeting.

How to Address Poor Employee Performance: 7 Effective Strategies

Let us know what you think...