Bad Exit, Bad Review: What to Do When Former Employees Go Public

By Grace Collins on May 02, 2025
3 min read 0 comment(s)

Share this:

Slammed Online: How to Handle Bad Reviews by Ex-Employees

In today’s digital world, just one disillusioned ex-employee can wreak havoc on an employer’s reputation. Even a single viral tweet can impact sales, morale and recruitment efforts—sending company leaders scrambling to manage the fallout.

But employers aren’t powerless. With the right approach, businesses can take both proactive and reactive steps to reduce the chances of a public online takedown and minimize damage if one occurs.

In this Ask the Expert, we’ll explore how employers can reduce the risk of receiving negative online reviews from former employees—and what to do if a disgruntled ex-employee takes to public platforms like Glassdoor or Indeed to share damaging feedback. From prevention to response, these best practices can help protect your reputation and reinforce your company’s values.

New call-to-action

Proactive Prevention: Reducing the Risk Before It Starts

Former employees who feel mistreated are the most likely to post damaging reviews. A thoughtful, consistent approach to employee relations—especially around discipline and offboarding—can make a major difference. These best practices can help:

Set Expectations Early and Often

  • Don’t catch employees off guard. Offer regular, constructive feedback.

  • Clearly outline performance expectations and the consequences of not meeting them.

Document Performance Issues Consistently

  • Keep written records of performance problems.

  • Provide employees with opportunities to improve before moving to termination.

End on a Respectful Note

  • Show appreciation for departing employees—whether they resign or are let go.

  • Conduct exit interviews to gather insight and leave the door open for honest feedback.

Stay Professional During Termination

  • Remain calm, even if the employee isn’t.

  • Avoid any action that could be perceived as retaliatory—it's both unprofessional and potentially unlawful.

How to Minimize the Impact When an Employee Quits Without Notice

Nullifying a Bad Review: Smart Responses That Protect Your Brand

It’s important to stay aware of what’s being said about your company online. Negative reviews don’t just disappear—but how you respond can shape how future employees (and customers) perceive your culture.

Monitor Your Online Reputation

  • Set up Google Alerts for your company name.

  • Use free or paid tools to monitor reviews across job boards and social platforms.

Establish a Response Plan

  • Designate someone on your HR or PR team to handle negative reviews.

  • If you don’t have in-house expertise, partner with a PEO or PR firm you can call when needed.

Respond Thoughtfully

  • Respond within 24 hours whenever possible.

  • Thank the reviewer for their feedback—even if it's negative.

  • Use calm, neutral language (e.g., “We’re sorry to hear this was your experience.”).

  • Avoid defensiveness, and cite relevant policies only if helpful.

  • Tailor each response—skip the canned messages.

  • Have someone else review your draft before posting it.

Know When to Escalate or Stay Silent

  • Point out privacy laws if applicable and avoid sharing internal details.

  • Don’t argue online—it often backfires.

  • If the review includes false, damaging claims, consult legal counsel.

  • In some cases—especially during litigation or clear cases of “sour grapes”—no response is the best response.

Look for Patterns

  • Trends in negative reviews may reveal real issues that need attention.

  • Use recurring feedback as a roadmap for improving culture and retention.

Protecting Your Brand Starts with Smart HR Strategy

While you can’t prevent every bad review, how you respond—both internally and externally—can make all the difference. Former employees aren’t just reflecting on their own experience; they’re shaping how future talent views your organization.

RELATED: Signs an Employee Is Going to Quit >>

Need Help Managing Reputation Risks?

Axcet HR Solutions partners with small and mid-sized businesses to navigate challenging employee relations and protect employer branding—from offboarding best practices to smart online reputation management.

Let’s create a strategy that protects your people and your reputation. Talk to an Axcet HR Consultant today »

Subscribe now

Written by Grace Collins

Get HR Updates

Table of Contents

Related Resources

Too Casual for Work? How to Address Summer Dress Code Violations

Axcet HR Director meeting with her team to discuss workplace dress code violations
Axcet HR Solutions consultant sharing expert advice on no-call/no-show employee policies

No Call No Show Employees: What to Do When They Reappear

Let us know what you think...