Knowing how to resolve conflict between two employees is a critical skill for business owners, managers, and HR professionals alike. Even in the healthiest workplace cultures, disagreements can arise—whether due to personality clashes, communication gaps or misaligned expectations.
Left unchecked, employee conflict can quickly disrupt team dynamics and hurt productivity. That’s why strong HR conflict resolution practices and proactive conflict mediation strategies are essential.
This guide outlines a step-by-step approach to resolving workplace disputes with professionalism, empathy and long-term results in mind.
Sound conflict mediation strategies help prevent minor disagreements from escalating into full-blown disputes. Addressing conflict between employees promptly and professionally reinforces your company’s commitment to respect, trust, and teamwork.
Here’s how to resolve conflict between two employees with an effective, HR-driven approach:
Start by setting the tone. A neutral, private setting fosters openness and reduces pressure. As the mediator, clarify that your goal is not to pick sides but to help both parties work toward resolution.
To lay the groundwork for effective conflict mediation:
Choose a confidential setting with no distractions
Establish ground rules for respect and civility
Reinforce that the conversation is solution-focused
Without psychological safety, employees may stay guarded—or escalate. Creating a neutral space encourages honesty and signals your commitment to fair and constructive HR conflict resolution.
Let each employee share their perspective without interruption. Encourage them to express thoughts and feelings respectfully and ask the other party to truly listen, not just wait for their turn to speak.
Make it easier with these tips:
Set time limits to ensure equal airtime
Paraphrase back key points to show understanding
Ask neutral clarifying questions if needed
Employee conflict often intensifies when people feel unheard. Active listening builds trust, diffuses emotion and lays the foundation for collaborative problem-solving.
RELATED: How to De-Escalate a Situation at Work >>
One of the most important parts of learning how to resolve conflict between two employees is keeping the conversation focused on the core issue, not the past or personal attacks.
To keep the focus on resolution:
Ask each employee to explain what they believe the conflict is about
Look for common threads in their perspectives
Gently redirect the conversation if it veers into personal attacks
Many workplace disputes stem from misunderstandings or unmet expectations. Identifying the real issues ensures your conflict mediation efforts solve the right problems.
Much of the tension in employee conflict comes from assumptions. Clarify key points on both sides and check for misinterpretation—especially around tone, intent, and expectations.
To uncover misunderstandings:
Have each person restate what they heard the other say
Clear up inaccurate assumptions or exaggerated statements
Highlight any shared goals or mutual respect
Even well-meaning employees can misread each other. Clarifying misunderstandings creates “aha” moments that reduce defensiveness and pave the way for reconciliation.
A critical part of how to resolve conflict between two employees is allowing them to help shape the solution. After all, they’re more likely to follow through on steps they helped create.
Brainstorm ideas such as:
Adjusting communication styles or frequency
Reallocating responsibilities or clarifying roles
Creating shared check-ins to stay aligned
Reestablishing team norms or boundaries
When employees participate in building the solution, they’re more committed to making it work. Collaborative problem-solving is at the heart of effective conflict mediation.
RELATED: How to Have Difficult Conversations with Employees >>
With potential solutions in hand, it’s time to decide on clear, actionable next steps. Documenting this agreement ensures accountability and provides a reference point if issues re-emerge.
Effective action planning may include:
A written summary of agreed-upon expectations
A follow-up meeting to revisit progress
Defined consequences if behavior doesn’t change
Even the best intentions fade without follow-through. Clearly defined steps create structure, accountability and a shared sense of commitment.
Follow-up is one of the most overlooked steps in how to resolve conflict between two employees—but it’s where resolution becomes sustainable. Check in with both employees after a reasonable time frame to assess progress.
Strong follow-up includes:
Private check-ins with each employee
Recognition of improved behavior or collaboration
A plan for addressing repeat issues if necessary
HR conflict resolution doesn’t end with one conversation. Follow-up reinforces that the issue matters and that leadership is invested in maintaining a respectful, productive workplace.
While learning how to resolve conflict between two employees is essential, prevention is just as important. A strong workplace culture can reduce both the frequency and intensity of employee conflict. Consider these proactive strategies:
Encourage open communication so employees feel comfortable expressing concerns early
Set clear expectations around responsibilities, roles and behavior
Offer training in communication and conflict resolution skills
Check in regularly with your team to uncover tension before it escalates
Model respectful interactions from the top down
Celebrate diversity of thought, while fostering team alignment and mutual respect
RELATED: Staying Out of Harm's Way - How to Handle Disgruntled Employees >>
Knowing how to resolve conflict between two employees is about more than just restoring peace—it’s about strengthening your team. With the right approach to HR conflict resolution, even tense situations can become turning points that lead to better communication, deeper trust and a stronger workplace culture.
Need expert support? Axcet HR Solutions is a certified PEO with award-winning HR professionals who can guide you through employee mediation, policy development and building a more resilient organization.
👉 Talk to an Axcet HR Solutions expert today >>